No-medical or fully underwritten life insurance: which one do you actually want?

Fully underwritten usually wins on price if you are healthy and patient. No exam wins on speed and certainty. How to tell which is yours.

Life Insurance Advisor & Mentor · 8 min read
A considering man in his late thirties in an olive sweater, beside the headline comparing no exam and fully underwritten life insurance on a branded Oneday card.
On this page
  1. Key takeaways
  2. What are the actual routes in Canada?
  3. When does the exam route genuinely win?
  4. When does no exam win?
  5. What does the medical exam involve?
  6. What does the no-exam route ask instead?
  7. What does no exam cost?
  8. The catch, said out loud
  9. How to decide in two minutes
  10. Conclusion
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. Sources

If you are young, healthy, patient and buying a large amount, a fully underwritten policy with a medical exam will usually cost you less per dollar of coverage. For everyone else, no medical exam is the better trade. That is the honest answer, and it is worth saying plainly before anything else, because most pages comparing the two are selling one of them.

The real decision rests on three things: how your health actually reads on paper, how much time you are willing to spend, and how much coverage you need. This guide walks through each route, what it costs, what the exam involves, and how to tell within two minutes which one is yours.

What are the actual routes in Canada?

Three, and the names get used loosely, so here is what each one really means.

RouteWhat you giveDecision
Fully underwrittenLong questionnaire, medical exam, often a doctor's reportTypically several weeks
Simplified issueHealth questions only, no examWithin 24 hours
Guaranteed acceptanceAge and residency onlyImmediate, always yes

Oneday sits in the second and third rows. One application of 14 questions places every applicant, and the guaranteed rung sits underneath as a floor nobody applies for separately. The detail is in our guide to no medical exam life insurance in Canada.

When does the exam route genuinely win?

More often than a no-exam provider will usually admit. Take it seriously if all of these are true:

  • Your health reads well on paper. Not just "I feel fine", but numbers a lab would like.
  • You want a large amount, above what no-exam routes cap at. The pricing gap widens as the coverage grows.
  • You are not in a hurry. Several weeks is genuinely fine for you.
  • Nothing on your record worries you. No recent diagnosis, no previous decline.

Insurers price what they can measure. Give them a clean set of measurements and they will charge you less for the same risk, because the uncertainty premium disappears. That is not a trick, it is the whole logic of underwriting.

When does no exam win?

When any one of these is true, and most people have at least one.

  • Speed matters. A new mortgage, a new baby, a divorce settlement, a lender asking.
  • You have a condition that makes the traditional outcome uncertain, even a well-managed one.
  • You have been declined before, which makes another traditional application a risk rather than a plan.
  • You will not actually book the exam. This is the honest one. Plenty of people start the traditional route and quietly abandon it, ending up with nothing for years.

The last point deserves more weight than it usually gets. A cheaper policy you never finish buying costs more than a slightly dearer one that is in force.

What does the medical exam involve?

Usually a paramedical visit at home or at a clinic: height, weight, blood pressure, a blood sample and a urine sample. Sometimes an electrocardiogram at higher amounts or older ages. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada notes that insurers "may require that you complete a medical questionnaire or exam before approving you for a policy."

None of it is painful. What it is, is scheduled. Someone else's calendar, a lab's turnaround, and sometimes a request to your doctor that sits in an administrative pile. Our guide on what to expect in a life insurance medical exam covers the visit in detail.

What does the no-exam route ask instead?

Fourteen plain-language health questions plus your height and weight, with no exam, no blood work and no doctor's note at any age or amount. The questions ask about control and history rather than simply whether a diagnosis exists, which is why two people with the same condition can receive different offers.

Your answers decide the coverage available, the price, and whether a deferral applies. They do not decide whether you get an offer. Our guide on what the health questions actually ask goes through them.

What does no exam cost?

CoverageAge 35Age 45Age 55
$100,000$20.00 / mo$20.00 / mo$41.04 / mo
$250,000$27.68 / mo$45.45 / mo$98.55 / mo
$500,000$52.65 / mo$88.20 / mo$194.40 / mo

These are Oneday’s own illustrative monthly rates for our 10-year term life insurance at our best rate class: female non-smoker, age nearest birthday, including the $30 annual policy fee. Pricing from other insurance providers and carriers will vary. $20.00 is the minimum monthly premium. Not an offer of insurance; your rate is shown during the application, before any payment is taken. Underwritten by Humania Assurance Inc.

We will not publish a comparison table of what a fully underwritten policy would cost you, because that depends on an exam nobody has taken yet. What we can say is that the gap exists, it favours healthy applicants, and it narrows as health history gets more complicated. If you want the arithmetic by decade, see what life insurance costs at 55 in Canada.

The catch, said out loud

Some no-exam offers carry a 24-month deferral. Accidental death is paid in full from day one, death from natural causes inside the window returns every premium paid, and after 24 months the full amount is payable for any cause. Healthier answers get full coverage immediately with no deferral at all.

That is the real cost of skipping the exam, and it is the thing a fully underwritten policy does not have. Whether it matters depends entirely on which offer your answers produce. The full explanation is in our guide on what a 24-month deferral actually means.

How to decide in two minutes

Get the no-exam price first, because it is free, takes about a minute and needs no email address. Then you are comparing a real number against a hypothetical one rather than two hypotheticals.

  • If the no-exam price looks fine to you, take it. The money you might save elsewhere is not worth weeks of uncertainty to most people.
  • If it looks high and you are genuinely healthy, get an exam-based quote too. You have lost nothing by looking.
  • If your offer carries a deferral, that is information about how your health reads. Factor it into whether the traditional route is realistic for you at all.

Conclusion

This is not a case where one product is better. It is a trade between price and certainty, and which side you should take depends on facts about you rather than facts about the products. Healthy and patient, take the exam. Anything else, take the speed and the guaranteed offer.

If you want to talk it through rather than decide alone, a licensed advisor is on 1 800 655 2795. Every policy here carries a 30-day free look, so you can read the contract at home and get a full refund if it is not what you expected.

Frequently asked questions

Is no medical exam life insurance more expensive?

Usually yes, per dollar of coverage, for someone who would have sailed through an exam. The insurer is pricing a risk it has not measured, and that uncertainty costs something. For applicants with any health history, the gap narrows or disappears, because the traditional route would have priced that history too, or declined it.

Which is better, simplified issue or fully underwritten?

Neither is better in general. Fully underwritten wins on price for healthy applicants who want large amounts and can wait several weeks. Simplified issue wins on speed, on certainty of receiving an offer, and for anyone whose health makes the traditional outcome uncertain.

How much can I get without an exam?

Up to $500,000, depending on your answers and age. The healthiest answers open up to $500,000 to age 70 and $150,000 from 71 to 80. More complicated answers open up to $350,000, then $100,000 as permanent coverage. A guaranteed acceptance offer of $50,000 to age 50, or $25,000 from 51 to 80, sits underneath every application.

What happens if a traditional insurer declines me?

A decline goes on your record and later applications ask about it, which is why applying traditionally is not risk-free. A no-exam application does not carry that risk here, because every applicant aged 18 to 80 in our provinces receives an offer rather than a decline.

Does a medical exam hurt or take long?

The visit itself is short and routine: height, weight, blood pressure, and blood and urine samples, usually at home or at a clinic. The time cost is not the appointment, it is everything around it. Booking, lab turnaround, and sometimes a request to your doctor that waits in an administrative queue.

Can I apply both ways at once?

You can, and some people do. The sensible order is to get the no-exam price first, since it is free, takes about a minute and requires no email address. That way you are comparing a firm number against an estimate rather than two estimates.

Does no exam mean no health questions?

No. Simplified issue means no exam but still 14 health questions plus height and weight. Guaranteed acceptance is the route with no health questions at all, and it is the smallest offer with a deferral attached. People often use the phrase "no medical" to mean both, which is where the confusion starts.

Will my premium change later?

No. Once you are approved, the premium is locked for the whole term and the coverage cannot be cancelled because your health changes. That is true on both routes. What differs is the starting price and how long you waited for it.

Where is Oneday available?

Oneday is available in seven provinces: Ontario, British Columbia, Alberta, Manitoba, Saskatchewan, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia. We are not currently available in Quebec, Newfoundland and Labrador, Prince Edward Island or the territories.

Who underwrites my policy?

Every Oneday policy is underwritten by Humania Assurance Inc., a Canadian insurer established in 1874. Oneday TPA Inc. is a third-party administrator, which means we handle the application, the service and the technology while the insurance itself sits with Humania.

Sources

Keep reading

Related guides.

Find out in 60 seconds if we can cover you.

No email required. Rates are set by your age at application and go up on your birthday, checking today locks in today’s age.

Check my price

4.9/5 across 300+ Reviews.io reviews